Comparing 2 Takumar 55mm Lenses

The Takumar 55mm lens was produced in Japan by Pentax ( Asahi Optical) and went through a number of iterations (9 by reputable sources). My copies are the “super” version, specifically the “interim” designation, and the SMC (Super Multi-coated) version, the last series to be produced. I was curious to see if the super multi coating changed the image quality in any significant way to the earlier version, or if there were any other noticeable differences. These were shot on my Sony A7R2 camera.

In the first shot I set up, I focused on some dead leaves on a manzanita bush, a subject I previously has a lot of success with, and opened both lenses wide and two the shots one after another. There did not seem to be any significant difference between the two images.

The second set of shots gave a slightly different result, but part of it may have been that the aperture on the first lenses may not have been all the way open, having been bumped while changing lenses. The earlier lens appears to display more pink tones.

The Third Image shows the same slight (very slight) pinkish hue to the image but the difference is very slight.

The last image also shows the slight difference in hue, but the difference is so small as to be debatable. Never the less, the tonal rendition on the newer lens is more pleasing to my eye.

This was a very limited comparison, and if I’m feeling inspired I’ll do additional testing in more challenging lighting conditions, to see if the coatings have any other effects. For now, despite the lower build quality and less pleasure in use, I’m leaning towards the SMC lens for image quality.

Published by Richard

I am a writer, photographer, and contemplative. My highest value is beauty and excellence. I seek to find and appreciate it, and create it. My second value is truth. I try to clearly and accurately communicate what is real and true. My third value is kindness. I study religion and science to help me understand how to increase kindness in myself and others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: